A few weekends ago we took our 2 daughters to see Kit Kittredge: An American Girl. I’m not sure whether the movie is even still in theaters, so this review is late, but might be interesting to people once it is released on DVD. Our older daughter, 8, is a big Ameri
can Girl fan. The 3.5 year-old is pretty much interested in anything the older one likes.
I would recommend this movie to parents with children in this age range, and maybe up to 10 or so. Also, although it is clearly a movie designed for girls, I think boys would enjoy it also. You might not make it your first choice for a boy, but if you have both boys and girls in your group, it should definitely be on your list.
The story is set in Cincinnati, a few years into he Depression, right around the time that previously secure people started losing their businesses and their homes. As such, it is a useful vehicle to start talking to your children about economics, responsibility, poverty, and related issues. On such issues, the movie presents a vaguely liberal point of view, but nothing that should get leftists too excited or righties too agitated about. I thought it presented good teaching moments. For example, a few people lose their home or business when they cannot make loan payments and the bank forecloses. In many movies, I would expect them to demonize the bank, but they didn’t do that here. This gave me the chance to explain to my daughter that in the depression, a lot of banks failed because people didn’t pay back their loans, so it is necessary to understand why the banks had to foreclose, so they could try to stay afloat and to be able to pay back money to the people who deposited it. Of course, I also told her that the people who didn’t pay back weren’t bad people either. This then led to a larger discussion about how some poeple end up poor because of a bad economy, or because someone gets sick and can’t work, or other reasons out of their control, and yet there also are people who just don’t want to work or make bad choices. You can’t generalize, or assume anybody is in one camp or another based on assumptions. I’ll spare you the rest of my basic economic musings for 8-year olds, but I hope I conveyed the point that the movie is a useful vehicle for addressing such issues with your children.
Apart from that, the movie is a pretty basic kids mystery, with a Nancy Drew/Hardy Boys element. Somebody is committing crimes, and manipulating evidence to make it look like vagrants are doing it, leading to fear of a nationwide hobo crime spree. Our heroine Kit solves the crime, saving a friend, her house, and her family in one fell swoop. The actual wrongdoers turn out to be a rather bumbling lot once they are identified, so there is not much to scare the younger ones. I would definitely recommend watching this one with your children, and discussing it afterwards.